Comparisons 7 min read

    Repair or replace — how we decide, and when we say repair

    An installer telling you to replace everything has an obvious incentive. So here's the framework we actually use on survey, including the cases where we recommend a repair and walk away from a bigger sale.

    The short answer

    Repair when the frame is sound and the fault is a seal, hinge, handle or glass unit. Replace when the frame itself has failed, parts are obsolete, or repair costs approach 40% of replacement.

    Start with the frame, not the symptom

    The frame is the only part that can't be swapped out in isolation. Glass units, gaskets, hinges, handles and locks are all consumable — the frame is the asset.

    If the frame is square, solid and sealing to the brickwork, almost everything else is a repair. If the frame is twisted, cracked at the welds, or the reinforcement inside has corroded, you're replacing regardless of what else you do.

    The four repairable faults

    Misted or blown double glazing: the sealed unit has failed, not the window. A replacement unit into a sound frame is a fraction of the cost of a new window.

    Draughts: usually perished gaskets or a dropped sash. Re-gasketting and hinge adjustment fixes most of them.

    A door that won't lock: normally a misaligned keep or a worn multi-point gearbox. Both are parts jobs.

    A broken handle or hinge: a direct swap where the part is still available.

    • Misted / blown sealed units → replace the unit
    • Draughts on a sound frame → re-gasket and adjust
    • Door won't lock → realign keeps or replace the gearbox
    • Failed handle, hinge or cylinder → part replacement

    When replacement is the honest answer

    Obsolete hardware. Systems from the 1980s and early 90s frequently have no available spares, and a bodged non-matching part fails again quickly.

    Multiple simultaneous faults. Three repairs on one 25-year-old window rarely make sense against one new A-rated unit that comes with a guarantee.

    The 40% rule: once quoted repairs pass roughly 40% of the replacement price, replacement is normally the better value over any reasonable time horizon.

    What we'd tell you at survey

    If your frames are under 15 years old and the problem is glass or seals, we'll say a repair specialist is the better call — and we'd rather you came back to us in ten years than felt pushed now.

    If they're 25 years old with corroded reinforcement, we'll show you the evidence at the frame rather than asking you to take it on trust.

    Get a diagnosis before a quote

    We'll tell you which of your openings need replacing and which only need a repair specialist — in writing.

    Comparisons — common questions

    Get a Free Written Quote

    Tell us what you need and our Leicester team will provide a clear, no-pressure quote.

    ✓ 40+ years local ✓ 10-year insurance-backed guarantee ✓ Free no-pressure survey